So how did the shadows stack up??
 |
| MAC right eye End of Day |
 |
| Joe Fresh right eye End of Day |
 |
| Maybelline right eye End of Day |
 |
| Make up For Ever right eye End of Day |
 |
| NYX right eye End of Day |
Monday - MAC Paint Pot, C+
Tuesday - Joe Fresh Cream Eye Shadow, F
Wednesday - Maybelline Tattoo Eye Colour, B
Thursday - MUFE Aqua Cream, B+
Friday - NYX Jumbo Pencil, B+
Not a terrible group - I like to think that I covered various brands and price ranges.
I really did toss the Joe Fresh one, it was an awful experience.
Lets talk costs (also in per gram):
MAC, $21/5g, $4.20/g
Joe Fresh, $6/1.8g, $3.33/g
Maybelline, $6.49/6g, $1.08/g
MUFE, $25/6g, $4.17/g
NYX, $5.99/5g, $1.20g
I really am struggling with picking a clear winner. In essence there are 4 that I would consistently use. Noting that primer and a powder shadow on top is a requirement. But when I look at the pictures, the NYX one looks to be the most intact!
MAC and MUFE would be ones I would buy less often, cost being the main factor. If I was looking for a less expensive alternative with a colour range I would definitely go with NYX. But there are a couple of Maybelline shadows I am going back to get.... I can't help it!
Cheers!
Lori
Your shadow comparisons are great! Amazing that NYX performed the best. - Sheila, Painted Ladies
ReplyDelete